| Platinum | Oakwood Pizza & Subs |
| Gold | Ferraro's Restaurant and Pizza |
| Silver | LouCas |
| Bronze | Villa Gennaros |
| Top Pick | Carmen's Trattoria |
| Top Pick | Catherine Lombardi Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Edison Pizza & Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Francesco's Pizzeria & Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Our Place Pizza |
| Top Pick | Villa Fresh Italian Kitchen |