| Platinum | Metuchen Inn |
| Gold | Villa Gennaros |
| Silver | Lou Cas |
| Bronze | Edison Diner |
| Top Pick | Edison Tex Mex Deli |
| Top Pick | Ferraro's Pizzeria & Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Fontainbleau Diner Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Le Peep |
| Top Pick | Old Man Rafferty's |
| Top Pick | Skylark Diner |